top of page
Search

Our Students Are Doing Great: The UC Admissions Data in Context

Oct 18
4 min read

Rosa's opponent keeps telling voters that on Rosa Kim's watch, Berkeley and UCLA admission offers fell 40% at Monta Vista and 27% at Homestead. The data analysis method is misleading. The conclusion is problematic.


His own website now admits that trustees don't control admissions. But the message he leaves with families is still a question about our kids: are Monta Vista and Homestead students falling behind? We went back to the same public UC data he used, and added state records on class sizes and on where graduates enroll. The answer is absolutely no. Our students are getting into UC at the highest rates since at least 2010.


Four problems with the "40%" claim


  1. It blames Rosa for years before she took office. Rosa was sworn in in December 2018. His chart starts in 2010 and compares the 2010–17 average with 2018–25. The class of 2018 received its decisions in spring 2018, before her term began. Monta Vista's sharpest single drop came in 2017, when its UCLA offers fell from 63 to 42. A comparison built on pre-2019 years does not measure her record.

  2. It counts the same students twice. UC publishes each campus's numbers separately. Adding Berkeley and UCLA together counts a student who applied to both as two applications, and a student admitted to both as two offers. The only figure UC publishes without double counting is the total for the whole UC system. The opponent's 40% measures offers, not students.

  3. It ignores a shrinking senior class. Monta Vista graduated 593 seniors in 2018 and 434 in 2025, 27% fewer. Fewer seniors means fewer applications and fewer offers. Per graduate, Monta Vista's Berkeley and UCLA offers fell about 23% over those years, not 44% ignoring this factor. The opponent campaigns on declining enrollment, then counts the smaller class against our students.

  4. It ignores what happened across California. UC stopped using SAT and ACT scores in admissions starting with students applying in fall 2020, and freshman applications jumped about 19% in a single year. From 2010–17 to 2018–25, Berkeley and UCLA applications from California public high schools rose 48% while offers rose only 4%. Gunn High in Palo Alto saw its Berkeley and UCLA offers fall 29%, and Saratoga High 28%, over the same years. "More applications, fewer offers" describes high schools across the state. It is not evidence of a problem in FUHSD.


What the data shows since Rosa took office

The fair test of Rosa's record starts with the class of 2019, the first to receive decisions after she was sworn in. Every figure below is adjusted for class size: offers or admits per 100 students in each school's graduating cohort.


At Monta Vista, Berkeley offers per student were slightly higher in 2023–25 than in 2019–21. UCLA offers fell, continuing a drop that began in 2017, before Rosa's term.

At Homestead, Berkeley offers per student rose and UCLA offers held flat throughout Rosa's term. Homestead's 2023 Berkeley rate was among its highest since 2010.


More of our students are getting into UC than at any time since 2010


UC's university-wide figure counts each student once, however many campuses admit them. It is the one number that answers the question families care about: did my child get into UC?

Three in four Monta Vista students and half of Homestead students now get into UC, the highest shares for both schools since at least 2010.
Three in four Monta Vista students and half of Homestead students now get into UC, the highest shares for both schools since at least 2010.

Three in four Monta Vista students and half of Homestead students now get into UC, the highest shares for both schools since at least 2010.


Many of our best students choose to leave California, or go private


Counting only Berkeley and UCLA misses where many of our strongest students actually go.

At Monta Vista, between 36% and 44% of every class since 2015 enrolled at an out-of-state or California private college, nearly all at four-year schools. At Homestead that share has topped 30% in each of the last three classes on record. These are choices, not rejections: in fall 2023, 352 Monta Vista students were admitted to UC and 150 enrolled.


Summary

  • The opponent's 40% and 27% are numbers used to make a false point. They lean on years before Rosa's term, count students twice, ignore Monta Vista's shrinking class, and ignore a statewide surge in UC applications.

  • Berkeley offers per student rose at both schools during Rosa's term (2019–21 vs. 2023–25). Homestead's UCLA offers held flat.

  • Monta Vista's UCLA offers did decline, first in 2017 before Rosa took office, then again in 2021–23, as Berkeley and UCLA admit rates fell across California.

  • More of our students get into UC than ever. From 2019 to 2025, the share of students admitted to at least one UC campus rose from 58% to 76% at Monta Vista and from 37% to 51% at Homestead, the highest for both schools since at least 2010.

  • Many of our graduates choose to leave California or go private: about 4 in 10 at Monta Vista, and about 3 in 10 at Homestead in recent years.

Our kids are not falling behind. Voters deserve the full picture, not a chart built to scare them.


Re-elect Rosa Kim for steady and honest leadership for strong FUHSD schools.


References

  1. University of California Office of the President, Admissions by Source School (updated March 12, 2026). Fall freshman applicants and admits by high school, per campus and universitywide.

  2. California Department of Education, Adjusted Cohort Graduation Rate files, classes of 2017–2026, and Cohort Outcome Data, classes of 2010–2016. Cohort size and diploma graduates by school.

  3. California Department of Education, College-Going Rate files (12-month), classes of 2015–2023. Where each school's graduates enrolled.

  4. EdSource, Why the University of California is seeing a massive surge in freshman applications, February 11, 2021.

  5. Jason Lin campaign, Why Now page, viewed October 18, 2026.

  6. Ballotpedia, Rosa Kim: FUHSD trustee since 2018.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
How FUHSD Board Governance Actually Works

Over the past two years, nearly every vote of the FUHSD Board of Trustees has been unanimous. Rosa works hard, through questions, public discussion, and listening to families and staff, to shape each

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page